When is a spreadsheet no longer enough?

A spreadsheet can be a brilliant tool. When keeping it working starts to become a job of its own, it’s worth asking what could be easier.

Spreadsheets earn their place. They are quick to start, easy to adapt and often exactly what a business needs. A well-kept spreadsheet can make a working day much easier.

Then, somewhere along the way, the spreadsheet becomes the booking system. Or the stock system. Or the thing everyone checks before they can answer a customer.

Extra tabs arrive. Someone adds a colour code. There is a second file for the exceptions, and a third that must never be renamed.

Notes being taken next to two laptop computers

Look at the work around the spreadsheet

The number of rows is only part of the story. A large, well-organised spreadsheet may do its job perfectly. A small one can cause trouble if it depends on constant copying, checking and remembering.

These are four useful signs that the process deserves a closer look.

  1. The same information keeps getting typed again

    A customer changes their address. You update the main list, then the booking sheet, then the document used to send their confirmation. Each copy creates another place to miss something.

    If a simple correction becomes a tour of several files, the work may benefit from one shared record that feeds the places it is needed.

  2. Nobody is quite sure which version to trust

    There is a copy in an email, one in a shared folder and another on somebody’s desktop. Before using the information, you have to establish which file is current.

    Sometimes clearer file ownership or a better shared setup will solve this. The point is to notice how much effort goes into finding a reliable starting point.

  3. Important rules live in someone’s head

    Only one person knows why column G must stay untouched, what the orange cells mean or which extra step is needed for a particular customer.

    That knowledge is valuable. A useful system should make the necessary rules visible and guide people through them, so the process can work when its usual keeper is away.

  4. Checking the work takes longer than doing it

    You finish entering the details, then compare two lists, look for missing rows and check the total against another report. The checking becomes a second version of the original job.

Some checks will always matter. Repeated reconciliation is a good reason to examine where the information comes from and how it moves.

Follow one ordinary job from start to finish

Choose something that happens regularly: an enquiry becoming a booking, a paper inspection becoming a report, or an order moving through the business.

Write down the steps as they happen today. Include the unofficial ones: the reminder on a sticky note, the message sent to a colleague and the list someone keeps separately.

For each step, ask:

  • Who needs to do something?

  • What information do they need, and where do they find it?

  • What gets copied, checked or chased?

  • What happens if the details change halfway through?

A rough page of notes is enough. Mark the steps that cause the most frustration. You now have a useful starting point for a conversation about improvements.

Start with the smallest change that would help

Imagine a team arranging service visits. An enquiry goes into one sheet, the appointment into another, and the job details onto a printed form. A date change means updating all three and making sure the person attending has seen it.

A better arrangement could begin with a single job record: the customer, appointment, job notes and current status together. The office and the person doing the work could see the parts they need. Fewer separate copies would need to be kept in step.

That is one possible improvement. The right answer might be a tidier spreadsheet, a ready-made application, a connection between existing tools or software built around the process.

Where people work matters too. A Windows or macOS desktop application might suit the office; a mobile app might suit people on site; a web application might make shared access easier. Those choices follow the work you need to do.

Keep what already works

The current spreadsheet contains useful knowledge: familiar terms, fields people rely on and reports that help them make decisions. Keep those in view when considering a change.

If records need to move, plan how they will be checked. Let the people doing the work try a representative task before the new process becomes part of their everyday routine.

If your spreadsheet is reliable, understandable and easy to look after, keeping it may be the sensible choice. When the workarounds are slowing the team down, it is worth looking at what could be easier.

Bring us the awkward bit

You do not need a technical specification. Tell us what happens now, what gets in the way and what a better working day would look like.

Our practical software examples show a few ways everyday spreadsheets and paper processes could change. If one sounds familiar, discuss a project with us. Rough notes are welcome.

Kevin Mullins

Kevin is a documentary photographer and educator with over 800 weddings under his belt and well over 1,000 students taught. He was the first Fujifilm Ambassador for Wedding Photography, an independent Fujifilm X Photographer, and co-host of The FujiCast photography podcast. Through workshops, online courses, and one-to-one mentoring, he helps photographers develop their own voice.

Based in the Cotswolds, he shares work and thoughts on Instagram, Threads and YouTube, and occasionally behind a microphone as a part-time radio DJ. He's a Black-Belt in Judo and British Judo Coach.

https://www.kevinmullinsphotography.co.uk
Previous
Previous

What to bring to a first conversation